A. Patrick Muñoz

Areas of Expertise

• Solid Waste Matters
• Local Government Law
• Land Use Law
• Special Education
• Civil Litigation
• General Counsel – Public and Private Entities

Public Law Career Highlights

Mr. Muñoz started with Rutan and Tucker’s Public Law Section in 1989 after graduating with honors from Loyola Law School. Soon thereafter he became Assistant City Attorney in the Cities of West Covina, Baldwin Park, San Fernando and Canyon Lake, as well as Deputy City Attorney in the City of Irvine.

In these roles, among other things, he assisted with the incorporation of the City of Canyon Lake and regularly participated as a speaker at the annual California Building Officials’ Conference. As Assistant City Attorney for San Fernando, he drafted an ordinance banning two warring gangs from a local park which withstood an A.C.L.U. challenge and served as a model for gang abatement in Los Angeles County.

In 1994 Mr. Muñoz became Twentynine Palms’ City Attorney. In this role for over 20 years he has assisted in a wide variety of projects including, perhaps most notably, the annexation of the Twentynine Palms Air Ground Combat Center. He also lead the City’s successful legal efforts to preserve its former Redevelopment Agency’s bond proceeds for use in a project intended to assist with the revitalization of the City’s historic downtown, and is now deeply involved in efforts to implement that economic development project in the post-Redevelopment Era designated City projects. In addition, he has recently assisted the City with a complex LAFCO proceeding whereby the City is facilitating the transfer of fire protection authority from the local water district to the County; and, thereby, ensuring a sustainable funding mechanism for ongoing fire protection service in the region.

Mr. Muñoz also serves as the General Counsel for the Morango Basin Transit Authority, which provides public transportation services in the communities of Twentynine Palms, Yucca Valley, and Joshua Tree.

The City of Dana Point appointed Mr. Muñoz as its City Attorney in 2002. As City Attorney, among other achievements, he led the City’s legal efforts related to the approval of the Headlands development by the California Coastal Commission, and successfully defended against related legal challenges to this approval. Since that time, he has been involved in countless matters involving Coastal development and related regulations on behalf of the City. He also successfully led the defense of a complex legal challenge to the City’s Housing Element by which opponents to a mobile home park closure sought to eliminate the City’s ability to exercise its land use authority in connection with any project. More recently, he lead the City’s legal team against efforts by the IRS to compel recreation class instructors to be classified as employees, rather than the common practice of classifying them as independent contractors. He also led Dana Point’s legal efforts by which it obtained judgments in excess of $7,000,000.00 against various marijuana dispensaries that were illegally operating in the City in violation of California’s medical marijuana laws.

Mr. Muñoz served as the City Attorney for the City of Adelanto from 2007 until 2009. In that role he was an integral part of the City’s legal team when, due to a severe economic downturn, it was forced to deal with the fallout of its default on a complex financing involving auction rate bonds and a so called “SWAP.” Through a complex combination of water and sewer rate increases, bond refinancing, and the sale of certain public properties his efforts enabled the City to successfully avoid filing for bankruptcy protection.

Mr. Muñoz has negotiated numerous solid waste franchise agreements, and agreements for recycling services at so called “MRFs”, including agreements in the cities of Santa Clarita, Santa Ana, Fullerton, Irvine, San Clemente, La Quinta, Dana Point, Twentynine Palms, Lynwood, Huntington Park and La Palma. He assisted the Orange County City Managers Association in negotiating an amendment with the County of Orange to the County’s Waste Disposal Agreement which directs flow of Countywide solid waste the County’s landfill system. Mr. Muñoz actively participated in the adoption of statewide regulations by the California Integrated Waste Management Board applicable to solid waste facility permitting, and in a related vein successfully defended a solid waste enterprise which was accused by the LEA and CalRecyle of operating in violation of these regulations. He has also successfully processed both local land use entitlements and State solid waste facility permits on behalf of solid waste enterprises.

Mr. Muñoz has handled numerous complex litigation matters on behalf of various cities. These cases have included landslide and flooding claims, challenges to the award of solid waste franchises, inverse condemnation claims, ADA claims, suits brought pursuant to 42 USC Section 1983, Coastal Act claims, CEQA claims, and writ challenges to development projects and ordinances. He has regularly handled cases before California’s appellate courts, and has appeared before the California Supreme Court.

Over the years Mr. Muñoz has been a speaker at a variety of League of California City committee meetings/conferences, and has assisted with updating the California Municipal Law Handbook. He has served as a volunteer moot court judge for the Constitutional Rights Foundation, has handled several pro-bono cases for Orange County’s Public Law Center, and has given numerous presentations on Legal Ethics to a variety of public officials.

Representative Cases

• City of Dana Point v. Beach Cities Collective (2014) (Docket No. G047839)
• City of Dana Point v. California Coastal Com. (2013) 217 Cal. App. 4th 170
• Ambac Assur. Corp v. Adelanto Public Utility Authority, U.S.D.C. Southern District of New York – 09 CIV 5087 (JFK),2011 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 131680, November 14, 2011
• Traudt v. City of Dana Point, Calif. Court of Appeal – 4th Dist – Div 3 – G044130, 199 Cal. App. 4th 886; 131 Cal. Rptr. 3d 887; 2011 Cal. App. LEXIS 1254, Sept. 30, 2011(Review granted)
• Dana Point Safe Harbor Collective v. Superior Court, Supreme Court of California S180365, 51 Cal. 4th 1; 243 P.3d 575; 118 Cal. Rptr. 3d 571; 2010 Cal. LEXIS 12366, December 9, 2010
• Weitzman v. City of Dana Point, Calif. Court of Appeal – 4th Dist – Div 3 – G036199, 2006 Cal. App. Unpub. LEXIS 11677, December 28, 2006
• Hamilton v. City Council of Dana Point, Calif. Court of Appeal – 4th Dist – Div 3 – G034788, 2005 Cal. App. Unpub. LEXIS 10130, November 7, 2005
• Santa Ana Food Market, Inc. v. Alcoholic Beverage Control Appeals Board, Calif. Court of Appeal – 4th Dist – Div 3 – G024485, 76 Cal. App. 4th 570; 90 Cal. Rprt. 2nd 523; 1999 Cal. App. LEXIS 1034, November 29, 1999
• Johnson v. San Bernardino County, U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals – No. 98-55062, 1999 U.S. App. LEXIS 5276, March 15, 1999

Publications

• “The Truth About Marijuana Dispensaries,” Orange County Lawyer, August 2011
• “Challenging the IRS on the Status of Independent Contractors,” Western City Magazine, July 2010

Awards & Honors

• Southern California Super Lawyers 2012-2018
• Daily Journal’s Top 25 Municipal Lawyers of 2011
• AV® Preemininent™ rating with LexisNexis/Martindale Hubbell

Community Affiliations

Mr. Muñoz has a long record of community service. He is currently a board member and Past President of the Board of the Orange Coast College Foundation and over the years he has been a board member of Prevent Child Abuse Orange County/The RAISE Foundation; Hoag Hospital Foundation’s 552 Club; Costa Mesa Chamber of Commerce’s CM 500; and the Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce. He has been a volunteer leader for the Newport Beach Little League and the Newport-Mesa YMCA Indian Princess organization. His volunteer efforts have been publicly recognized on numerous occasions including by:

• The 2001 Hoag Hospital Siracusa Award
• The 2005 Costa Mesa Chamber of Commerce and South Coast Metro Alliance Community Spirit Award, and
• The 2006 Hoag Hospital Dr. David Martyn Memorial Award

Memberships & Associations

• Junior Board, Southern California Golf Association
• Member, League of California Cities, City Attorney Department, FPPC Committee
• Member, Society of Fellows
• Member, William P. Gray Inn of Court